Bizarre arguments against freeway fail to convince

Ahwatukee Foothills News
12-9-05
Guest commentary
By Bobby Mota

I would like to respond to the ongoing freeway issue in Ahwatukee Foothills.

I'm an Ahwatukee resident and a homeowner in this community for several years. Fortunately, my home isn't directly affected by the freeway proposal. I knew the history of this project when I started looking for a home in Ahwatukee, so I avoided searching in this general area. From reading all the negative articles about this proposal, it sounds like many other residents should have done some research before they bought a house in this area as well. Past experience has taught me that government may move slowly, but once it moves nothing is going to prevent it from its goal. Now, almost 20 years later, the government is moving to complete this goal.

My response to this issue is not about this proposed route. I believe this route needs to be completed, even if it's where ADOT (Arizona Department of Transportation) is now proposing it. The entire community shouldn't be held hostage to appease a few. It's been in the works for 20 years, and those who moved into this area during this time knew of this issue. The real tragedy to the community is that ADOT allowed this to drag on for this long, which allowed more people and businesses to move in. Twenty years later and numerous meetings with the community, nothing has changed except a growing traffic problem. It's time that ADOT does what is best for the entire community and start building the freeway at Pecos Road. If there were any case for the city to invoke eminent domain, this would be it. It fits the guidelines in our constitution perfectly.

My real reason for writing this commentary is not my position on the freeway, but to the fascinating and bizarre responses as to why it shouldn't be built.

These residents who are against the freeway; they really want it built. They want the benefits it's going to bring. They want the easy access to Ahwatukee and other parts of the city. They want the reduced time on the road. They just don't want it in their back yard. Their proposal is to build it on Indian land in disguise of economic benefits to the Gila River Indian Community. In reality, it's just a ploy to make themselves feel good by presenting it in this format. This way they won't go around feeling sorry for themselves for what they did. If it's such a good economic benefit, why not put it at Pecos Road? If it's good enough to be built on Indian land, then it should be good enough to build it in our own back yard.

The most bizarre reason I heard for not building this freeway is from the lady who wrote that Ahwatukee would be threatened by child molesters who will have easy access to our community. When I read this I thought, how desperate can these people be? To write something like this is not only inaccurate, but it's irresponsible. Nothing in her letter to the editor provided us with any pertinent data that child molesters would come to Ahwatukee because of this freeway access. This was a cheap attempt to scare the community unnecessarily in order to promote her own self-interest.

Perhaps the only legitimate opinions I have read that give me some reservations about this freeway are those discussing the environment. Most of what I read were personal opinions from readers peppered with some scientific data. I'm sure there is a ton of data for both viewpoints that is available. When it's time to make a decision, I hope it's based on sound data and not deception and fear from those who only have their own self-interest at stake.

Bobby Mota is a resident of Ahwatukee Foothills.