Freeway plans win few proponents

Ahwatukee Foothills News
11-18-05
By Doug Murphy, Staff Writer

For some people at Thursday's open house on the proposed Loop 202 South Mountain Freeway the issue was simple.

"We have a nice view and a sound wall would ruin it," said Charles Whitaker whose home backs onto Pecos Road.

For others, the issues were more complex.

"What makes Ahwatukee special is that it is a cul-de-sac. We don't have through traffic affecting our quality of life. The freeway will open it up and take away what's special," said Chris Ruhge who lives near 27th Avenue and Pecos Road.

What they both had in common is that they, along with several hundred others all, appeared to be opposed to construction of the freeway along Pecos Road.

Even Congressman J.D. Hayworth expressed his opposition. In a letter to the Arizona Department of Transportation (ADOT) on Tuesday, the Republican lawmaker said a freeway would cause more problems than it would solve and that the no-build option should be strongly considered.

"I write in strong opposition to this plan, and with the lack of an alternative I must urge you to support the 'No Build Option,'" Hayworth wrote.

ADOT held the eight-hour open house at the Grace Inn at Ahwatukee so that people could get their first close-up look at how a freeway could impact homes and businesses along Pecos Road.

The proposed plan showed that about 255 homes would have to be demolished in Ahwatukee Foothills to make way for the freeway.

Most of the houses are between 24th Street and South 34th Way, near Kyrene de los Lagos Elementary School.

Many people were surprised and concerned that the freeway would come within feet of Liberty Lane and Kyrene de la Estrella Elementary School and Kyrene Akimel A-al Middle School as well as Kyrene de los Lagos Elementary which now backs up to Pecos Road.

"What about the major accidents that sometimes happen?" Janel Millen asked. "I think it's just too close to the schools."

Jeff Ludwig was concerned that South Mountain would trap pollution generated by heavy truck traffic on the freeway.

But for many people their opposition evaporated at the suggestion that the freeway move south onto the Gila River Indian Community.

John Wiedman thought that a freeway would be an economic boost for the Indians and their economic plans.

"It makes mores sense on Indian land," Wiedman said.

So far, after years of planning, the Gila River Indian Community has shown no interest in hosting a freeway, and in 1995 passed a resolution opposing a freeway on tribal lands.

Indian opposition to the freeway upset Teri Pinkstaff.

"They aren't negotiating with us," even though they will benefit from freeway access and "we are their customers," Pinkstaff said.

ADOT representatives declined to comment on the feedback until they had a chance to review the written remarks people made.

People could study detailed aerial photographs showing the freeway routes, including five options between 51st Avenue and the Interstate 10/Loop 101 interchange. One of those options, roughly along 71st Avenue, would require the destruction of 780 homes and 15 businesses.

Voters originally approved a half-cent sales tax to fund freeway construction in 1985 including the South Mountain Freeway from I-10 in Ahwatukee Foothills, west around South Mountain and reconnect with I-10 between 51st Avenue and the I-10/Loop 101 interchange. Because of money shortfalls, the freeway was never built. In 2004, voters in Maricopa County passed Proposition 400, which allocated $1.2 billion to construct the freeway.

For information, visit www.southmountainfreeway.com.

The reporter can be reached at (480) 898-7914 or by e-mail at dmurphy@aztrib.com.

 Loop 202 numbers

* Six lanes to begin, three in each direction, eventually growing to 10 total.

* Six intersections in Ahwatukee Foothills at: 40th and 24th streets, Desert Foothills Parkway, 17th, 25th and 51st avenues.

* 255 homes demolished in Ahwatukee Foothills to make way for the freeway.

* 780 homes demolished around 71st Avenue to make room for the freeway in Laveen.

* 1985 ­ year Maricopa County voters first approved the funds for the freeway.

* $1.2 billion earmarked in transportation sales taxes to pay for construction.

* 3.1 million ­ Maricopa County population in 2000.

* 5.21 million ­ Maricopa County population in 2021.

* 32 acres ­ minimum amount of South Mountain Park that will need to be used for the freeway.

* 2009-15 Construction period if the freeway is approved.